MD&A · 2024
In this section4 topics
Overview of Operations
Overview of Operations
Operation Results of the Company and Affiliated Company Overview
The Company and its affiliates operate the business of producing and distributing products in the form of multi-level marketing with products consisting of supplementary products, beauty products, daily-used products, and household products including plant supplement products. Currently, the total income of the company and affiliates are divided into 4 main groups which are
1. Multi-Level Marketing Income
2. Distribution Agents Income
3. Services Income
4. Other Income
The first three groups of income are from sales of goods and services which accounted for approximately 95.18%, 94.11%, and 93.62% of total income in the period 2022 to 2024 respectively. The total income in that period was 1,180.56 million Baht, 977.75 million Baht, and 977.75 million Baht respectively.
Operating Results & Financial Condition
Operating Results & Profitability
Operating Results Analysis
(1) Income
Total income for the year 2022 to 2024 were 1,180.56 million Baht, 977.75 million Baht, and 685.55 million baht, respectively.
A total income in the 2023 period decreased by 197.54 million Baht, or equivalent to 16.73 percent from the same period of the previous year, mainly due to a decrease in domestic sales from both the dietary supplement group, which is the company's number one selling product group, according to the economic situation and the low purchasing power of consumers, coupled with increased competition in the dietary supplement market and a decline in sales in the agricultural product group, that is the product group with the second highest sales volume due to the price of fertilizer both in the world market and in Thailand, which has decreased by approximately 30–40%, causing the company's products to priced at a level that is not much different from the market. At the same time, the company's income from exporting products to distributors abroad decreased. As a result of the economic situation and purchasing power of consumers in each country where the company has distributors, it is still in the recovery period, causing sales of products from distributors in each country to decline. As a result, product orders from Thailand have decreased as well.
The total income in the 2024period decreased by 292.20 million Baht, or 29.88 percent, from the same period of the previous year. The reasons for this decline were similar to those in 2023 compared to 2022. mainly due to a decrease in domestic sales income from the slowdown in consumption among domestic consumers. Coupled with the increasing competition in the food supplement market, sales in the agricultural product segment declined due to the continued drop in fertilizer prices in both the global and Thai markets, causing the company's products to price at a level that is not much different from the market. However, the company has increased its revenue by exporting its products to overseas distributors. This growth resulted from improvements in the economic situation and the purchasing power of consumers in countries where the company has distributors, particularly Cambodia and Malaysia, which have begun to recover and experience increased purchasing power. As a result, distributor sales in Cambodia and Malaysia improved, leading to higher orders for products from Thailand.
Product Sales Income through Businessmen
Revenue from merchandising through businessmen accounted for 89.53 percent, 92.38 percent, and 97.43 percent of total revenue for the period of 2022 to 2024 respectively. This income comes from the Multi-Level Marketing business, which is the sale of products from the company to consumers through businessmen who are members of the company with a remuneration paid to the members according to the system following the network hierarchy and the type of remuneration according to the company's business plan. The company has a total number of businessmen members.
The number of businessmen at the end of 2024 has decreased due to intense competition both in the network business industry and in the consumer product market that makes it easier to reach consumers through online channels, which not only allows consumers to order products through online channels conveniently and quickly but also makes consumers easier to become a product seller. Online sales, which are more prevalent in consumers' daily lives, have an impact in addition to the nature of network business, in which product sales take place through offline meetings. The company has anticipated and planned to deal with these events by driving through the company's main work plan with a combination of online and offline (O2O) marketing from 2024 onwards.
Revenue from merchandising through businessmen in the 2023’s period decreased by 154.82 million Baht or 14.63 percent mainly due to a decrease in domestic sales from both the dietary supplement group, which is the company's number one selling product group, according to the economic situation and the low purchasing power of consumers, coupled with increased competition in the dietary supplement market and a decline in sales in the agricultural product group, that is the product group with the second highest sales volume due to the price of fertilizer both in the world market and in Thailand, which has decreased by approximately 30–40%, causing the company's products to priced at a level that is not much different from the market.
Revenue from merchandising through businessmen the 2024’s period decreased by 303.87 million Baht, or 33.64 percent, compared to the same period in the previous year. The reasons for this decline were similar to those in 2023 compared to 2022. These include a decrease in sales of dietary supplements, which was influenced by the economic situation and weakened consumer purchasing power, along with increasing competition in the health supplement market. Additionally, sales in the agricultural product segment declined due to the continued drop in fertilizer prices in both the global and Thai markets, causing the company's products to price at a level that is not much different from the market.
Product Sales Income through Distributors
The company has distributors in 7 countries: Myanmar, Laos, Vietnam, Cambodia, Malaysia, Singapore and Philippines, where laws and business environments will differ in each country. The details can be summarized as follows.
Myanmar
Myanmar is one of the countries that is the company’s distributor and a network of businessmen under the branding Successmore is the second largest after Thailand. Distributors in Myanmar have 5 branches under the Successmore branding, namely Yangon, Mandalay, Taunggyi, Myitkyina, and Mawlamyine. Originally, Myanmar did not have clear direct selling laws, therefore, distributors in Myanmar have operated their direct sales business as usual. However, after the government of Myanmar by the Ministry of Commerce issued Notification No. 46/2018 to cease the direct selling business in Myanmar in September 2018, the distributors in Myanmar were unable to operate the business in the form of direct selling. They can be operated only at the point of sale or selling products to the final consumers. The distributors will pay the remuneration to their members in the form of a Commission Rebate based on the purchase amount, which is not a network business compensation plan. Currently, the Burmese government is considering establishing a new direct selling bill before issuing clear announcements or laws again.
Laos
Currently, distributors in Laos have 3 branches under the Successmore branding, namely Vientiane, Luang Phabang and Pakse. Laos has no clear laws regarding the direct selling network, that is, there are no requirements and limitations for conducting direct sales business. As a result, the company can operate network business freely but due to the limitation on the number of the population and the purchasing power of consumers, making the business based in Laos is still relatively low in scale. The company is expecting to continue growing in the future.
Cambodia
Currently, distributors in Cambodia have two branch under the Successmore branding, namely Phnom Penh and Kampong Cham, which direct selling law of the company is similar to Laos’s. Cambodia's law has no clear indication of conducting a direct sales network making the company can operate the network business freely but due to the limitation on the number of the population and the purchasing power of consumers. As a result, at present, the expansion of the business based in Cambodia is still increasing. In Cambodia, the compensation paid in the form of a network business will result in more people interested in the business and may cause the number of businessmen to grow rapidly in the future.
Vietnam
Currently, distributors in Vietnam have one branch under the Successmore branding, namely Hanoi with its legal restrictions related to operating a direct sales network. The operators have to apply for a license to operate a direct sales business first. At present, the company's distributors in Vietnam are in the process of submitting for a direct selling network license. After receiving the license, the company expects Vietnam to be a country that has continued growth in the number of businessmen due to the structure of population and purchasing power similar to Thailand. Moreover, the Vietnamese population is also interested in many types of Thai products.
Malaysia
Malaysia is one of the two new countries that the company has entered into an additional distributor appointment agreement in 2019. It currently has one branch, namely Selangor with its laws related to direct selling network business. Although it is in the early stages of business in Malaysia, the company has seen the potential and competence of people in the area, population, and the knowledge and understanding of dietary supplements well. It also expects that the number of businessmen in Malaysia will grow well despite the high competition in the business.
Singapore
Currently, distributors in Singapore have one branch under the Successmore branding, Singapore has opened up independent business operations to entrepreneurs in the direct selling network business which can conduct business as usual but it must be subject to law and fairness in operating business. With the limitation of the population and the fact that consumers pay more attention to comparing product quality and price before deciding to consume the product, as a result, the number of businessmen in Singapore is still very small. The company sees that appointing a distributor in Singapore will further enhance the confidence of consumers abroad and open up business opportunities to expand to other countries in the future, such as the Philippines, Indonesia, etc.
Philippines
Currently, distributors in Philippines have one branch under the Successmore branding, Philippines has opened up independent business operations to entrepreneurs in the direct selling network business which can conduct business as usual but it must be subject to law and fairness in operating business. With the limitation of the population and the fact that consumers pay more attention to comparing product quality and price before deciding to consume the product, as a result, the number of businessmen in Philippines is still very small. The company sees that appointing a distributor in Philippines will further enhance the confidence of consumers abroad and open up business opportunities to expand to other countries in the future, such as the Indonesia, etc.
In this regard, the product sales income through distributors accounted for 5.12 percent, 1.40 percent, and 4.29 percent of total income from 2021 to 2023’s period respectively, this income is generated from selling many products at a special price to the distributors, to distribute products to consumers through various channels.
Income from sales through distributors in 2023 decreased by 46.61 million Baht, or 77.16 percent, from the same period of the previous year. This was mainly because the economic situation and purchasing power of consumers in each country where the company has distributors are still in the recovery period, causing sales of products from distributors in each country to decline. As a result, product orders from Thailand have decreased as well.
Income from sales through distributors in 2024 increased by 15.64 million baht, or 113.33 percent, from the same period of the previous year. This growth resulted from improvements in the economic situation and the purchasing power of consumers in countries where the company has distributors, particularly Cambodia and Malaysia, which have begun to recover and experience increased purchasing power. As a result, distributor sales in Cambodia and Malaysia improved, leading to higher orders for products from Thailand.
Considering the income from selling products by distributors by countries during 2022–2024, it was found that most of the income is mainly from selling to Cambodia and Myanmar distributors, while the income from distributors in other countries accounted for a very small percentage compared to distributors in Cambodia and Myanmar due to the number of businessmen in other countries being relatively smaller and the brand perception and acceptance is not as popular as Cambodia and Myanmar. However, after the government of Myanmar announced it would suspend direct sales operations in September 2018, it has a significant impact on the business operation of distributors in Myanmar. The Company anticipates that after the law on direct sales business in Myanmar is clearer, income from sales to distributors in Myanmar is likely to return to the same level and grow in the future.
Service Income
Service income accounted for 1.23 percent, 0.44 percent, 0.31 percent and 0.44 percent of total income from 2022 to 2024’s period respectively. This income is from providing networking business-related advice such as general management, businessman management, marketing, accounting, tax planning, and information technology system to the company's distributors to provide standards in various operations and bring the company's products to sell in the same standard. The company has separated the service activities by allowing SPT, the company's subsidiary to manage these activities instead of transferring the service activities, training and seminars, and business consulting services to SPT to divide the business for the efficiency in the management of the service business group.
Service income in the 2023 period decreased by 2.1 million baht, or 40.70 percent, from the same period of the previous year, mainly due to the company changing the form of marketing activities organized for members from offline, which charged a fee, to online, which does not charge a fee but can reach an extensive target group and that members from other countries could take part in more online marketing events held in Thailand, the company lowered the service fees it charged from overseas distributors. That resulted in a decrease in the company's service income in 2024 decreasing from 2023.
Service revenue in 2024 increased by 9.91 million baht, or 323.85 percent, from the previous year because of the company’s expanded efforts in organizing offline marketing activities for overseas distributors to provide product knowledge, develop sales skills, and inspire participation in network business services that generate revenue, contributing to the increase in service income. Additionally, the company continues to offer online activities free of charge, allowing it to reach a wider audience. This approach ensures that all domestic and international members have continuous access to various engagement opportunities.
Other Income
Other income represents 4.81 percent, 4.94 percent, and 5.12 percent of total income across 2022–2024, respectively. This portion of income consists of income from membership maintenance fees each in the case of new applications and annual renewals, the copyright fee collected from distributors, which is the income from allowing distributors to use the company's brand (Brand Using Fee), and the income from selling souvenir products at the company's branches and headquarters, as well as other income such as net income from seminar ticket sales, interest income from banks, gain from foreign exchange, and income from the company's liquidity management through investing in financial instruments.
Other income in 2023 decreased by 3.33 million baht, or 5.85 percent, from the same period of the previous year. The decreasing membership leads to a decrease in member maintenance income. Meanwhile, sales of products from distributors in each country decreased. As a result, the agents' sales generated by allowing distributors to use product instruments in each country decreased.
Other income in 2024 decreased by 14.34 million baht, or 29.71 percent, from the same period of the previous year. This decrease was attributed to similar reasons as in 2023, specifically a decrease in membership, which in turn led to a decrease in member maintenance income. Meanwhile, sales of products from distributors in each country decreased. As a result, the agents' sales generated by allowing distributors to use product instruments in each country decreased.
(2) Sales Cost
The sales cost in 2022 to 2027 were 252.73 million Baht, 214.77 million Baht, and 252.73 million Baht respectively. The cost of sales comprises the cost of all products sold through businessmen and distributors channels.
The total sales cost in the 2023’s period decreased by 37.96 million Baht or 15.02 percent from the same period of the previous year, mainly due to the company having lower sales revenue through businessmen and distributors, which caused the cost of sales to decrease in the same direction.
The total sales cost in 2024’s period increased by 1.94 million Baht or 9.90 percent from the same period of the previous year, mainly due to the company having lower sales revenue through businessmen, which caused the cost of sales to decrease in the same direction.
Service Cost
Service costs in 2022 to 2024 equal to 3.80 million Baht, 2.14 million Baht, and 6.61 million Baht respectively. The service cost mainly consists of salary, and remunerations of the involved employees which the company allows SPT, a subsidiary of the company to operate all related services business.
Service costs in the 2023’s period decreased by 1.66 million Baht or 43.68 percent from the same period of the previous year consistent with the decreased in service income.
Service costs in the 2024’s period increased by 4.47 million Baht or 208.88 percent from the same period of the previous year consistent with the increased in service income.
(3) Gross Profit
The gross profits in 2022 to 2024 were 867.16 million Baht, 703.26 million Baht, and 422.39 million Baht, respectively. The gross profit margin ratios were 77.17%, 71.54%, and 61.61%, respectively.
Gross profit in the 2023’s period decreased by 163.90 million Baht or 18.90 percent from the same period of the previous year. The company is experimenting with marketing by selling products at discounts instead of giving commissions to buyers who are not interested in network marketing and want to use the company's products in large quantities. In addition, at the end of the year, the company adjusted its business strategy by reducing product prices and reducing points (point value: PV) in paying commissions. Reducing prices without changing product costs resulted in gross profit margins (GP) decreasing from 77.17% to 71.54%.
Gross profit in 2024 decreased by 280.87 million baht, or 39.94 percent, from the same period of the previous year due to a decline in domestic sales revenue. In the last quarter of the year, the company sold a substantial amount of products to deplete the stock before its expiration date, offering them at a discounted price and without commission. This strategy was implemented to test the market, especially targeting buyers who were not interested in network marketing but needed the company's products in large quantities. This strategy significantly contributed to the decline in the gross profit margin (GP), which dropped from 71.54% to 61.61%.
(4) Sales Expenses
Sales expenses in 2022 to 2024 were 582.16 million Baht, 500.69 million Baht, and 306.75 million Baht respectively.
Sales expenses mainly consist of businessman commission, advertising and sales promotion, variable executive remuneration, and employee expenses. In this regard, the businessman commission is the remuneration paid to the network businessmen according to the remuneration plan.
Sales expenses in the 2023 period decreased by 81.47 million Baht, or 13.99%, from the same period of the previous year due to the company's product sales decreasing. The main selling expenses are business commissions, and variable executive compensation decreased in the same direction.
Sales expenses in the 2024 period decreased by 193.94 million Baht, or 38.73%, from the same period of the previous year due to the company's product sales decreasing. The main selling expenses are business commissions, and variable executive compensation decreased in the same direction. In addition, the company manages employee expenses related to sales and marketing, which has also reduced expenses in this area.
(5) Administrative Expenses
Administrative expenses in 2022 to 2024 equal 116.15 million Baht, 135.71 million Baht, and 129.47 million Baht respectively.
Administrative expenses mainly consist of employee expense, depreciation and amortization, rental fee, consultant fee, and taxes.
Administrative expenses in the 2023 period increased by 28.75 million Baht, or 24.75 percent, from the previous year due to higher employee expenses at Chadhai Leasing Co., Ltd., which began its whole operations in 2023. In addition, the company has hired consultants to recommend marketing strategies and personnel management. Including the provision for doubtful debts of the company for Leasing Co., Ltd., which operates the business of lending and leasing used cars. These expenses did not exist during the same period of the previous year. As a result, administrative expenditures in the year 2023 will increase.
Administrative expenses in the fiscal year 2024 decreased by 6.24 million baht, or 4.60 percent, from the same period of the previous year. The main reason was the decrease in employee expenses at Chadhai Leasing Co., Ltd., a subsidiary in which the company holds 100% of the shares. In the previous year, the subsidiary was undergoing closure, leading to expenses related to monthly salaries and severance payments. However, the absence of these costs in 2024 led to reduced management costs. Additionally, this reduction resulted from the company's strict cost management measures, including closing underperforming branches that were not viable for long-term business operations and encouraging members to utilize online channels to drive business growth.
(6) Loss from Net Exchange Rate
The company had a net exchange loss in the period of 2022 to 2024 equal to 3.47 million Baht, 0.85 million Baht, and 0.00 million Baht due to exchange rate losses from overseas sales transactions in the countries with a 120-day trade term credit given to overseas dealers and US-charged fees. The cost of products and fees not received as of December 31 will be calculated based on the exchange rate on December 31 to find the loss (profit) from the exchange rate according to accounting standards.
(7) Profit before Financial Costs and Income Tax Expenses
The company had the profit before financial costs and income tax expenses for the period of 2022 to 2024 equal to 222.24 million Baht 119.68 million Baht, and 6.12 million Baht. The decrease in profit before financial costs and income tax expenses was mainly due to the decrease in revenue from domestic sales and sales through distributors. As a result, profit before finance costs and income tax expenses decreased.
(8) Financial Cost
Financial costs for the period of 2022 to 2024 were 2.83 million Baht, 2.30 million Baht, and 2.11 million Baht, respectively, representing 0.24 percent, 0.23 percent, and 0.31 percent of the total income. However, the company’s financial costs remain relatively small and insignificant compared to its overall operating performance. These costs primarily stem from interest payments. Since January 1, 2020, the company has recorded rental contracts with terms longer than one year as right-of-use assets following IFRS 16—Leases. The company recognizes the corresponding finance lease liabilities simultaneously with the right-of-use assets. Consequently, we recorded additional financial costs totaling 2.11 million Baht in 2024.
(9) Income Tax Expense
Income tax expenses for the period of 2022 to 2024 equal 48.74 million Baht, 28.31 million Baht, and 5.08 million Baht. The effective tax rate was 22.00%, 24.00%, and 127.00% of profit before income tax expenses.
(10) Net Profit
The net profit for the period of 2022 to 2024 was 170.67 million Baht, 89.07 million Baht, and (1.08) million Baht respectively, accounting for 14, 9.06, and (0.16) percent of total income (net profit margin). The decrease in the net profit margin in 2024 was a result of the company's lower revenue from sales of goods, lower revenue from services, and lower other incomes. While both sales expense and administrative expense were higher. As a result, the net profit margin decreased.
Liquidity & Capital Adequacy
Cash Flows from Operating Activity
Net cash inflow (outflow) from operating activity for the year 2022 to 2024 has a total of 56.51 million Baht, 93.17 million Baht, and (13.36) million baht respectively. This was mainly due to the profit from the operation, including the add back of non-cash items such as depreciation, amortization, assets, and liabilities for the unstable operations.
Cash Flow from Investing Activity
Net cash flow from investing activity in 2022 was in the total of 152.72 million Baht, this was due to the company investing in debt instruments in order to generate more returns for the company comparing to the past that company’s cash is mainly deposited with financial institutions.
Net cash flow from investing activity in 2023 was a total of 49.12 million Baht, mainly due to the company investing in debt instruments to generate more returns and profits than depositing cash with the institution's finances and giving short-term loans to other companies to receive returns likewise.
Net cash flow from investing activity in 2024 was a total of 4.26 million Baht, mainly due to the company investing in intangible assets and debt instruments to generate more returns and profits than depositing cash with the institution's finances and giving short-term loans to other companies to receive returns likewise.
Cash Flow from Financing Activity
The company had net cash outflow from financing activity in a total of 215.28 million Baht in 2022. This was mainly due to the dividend paid in the amount of 197.60 million Baht, the lease liabilities paid in the amount of 14.85 million Baht and the interest paid in the amount of 2.83 million Baht.
The company had net cash outflow from financing activity in a total of 168.07 million Baht in 2023. This was mainly due to the dividend paid in the amount of 139.50 million Baht, the lease liabilities paid in the amount of 16.43 million Baht and the interest paid in the amount of 2.30 million Baht.
The company had net cash outflow from financing activity in a total of 98.03 million Baht in 2024. This was mainly due to the dividend paid in the amount of 68.66 million Baht, the lease liabilities paid in the amount of 16.69 million Baht and the interest paid in the amount of 2.11 million Baht.
Asset Management Capability
Financial Status
Asset
Total assets at the end of 2022–2024 were 984.61 million Baht, 887.59 million Baht, and 750.46 million Baht, respectively. Main assets are current assets, accounting for 53.34 percent, 62.71 percent, and 63.95 percent of total assets, which consist of cash and cash equivalent, trade receivables and other receivables, and inventories.
Total assets as of 31 December 2023 decreased by 97.02 million Baht or 9.85 percent from 31 December 2022. This was mainly due to the decrease in cash from the company's interim dividend payment, which resulted in a decrease in total assets.
Total assets as of 31 December 2024 decreased by 137.13 million Baht or 15.45 percent from 31 December 2023, mainly due to cash was used to pay an interim dividend. As a result, the company's current assets decreased.
Current Asset
• Cash and Cash Equivalents
Cash and cash equivalents at the end of 2022 to 2024 were 251.83 million Baht, 226.02 million Baht, and 110.37 million Baht, consisting of cash, current account, savings account, etc.
Cash and cash equivalents as of 31 December 2023 decreased by 258.10 million Baht or 10.24 percent from 31 December 2022, mainly because of the company's use of cash to pay an interim dividend. As a result, cash and cash equivalents decreased.
Cash and cash equivalents as of 31 December 2024 decreased by 115.65 million Baht or 51.17 percent from 31 December 2023, mainly because of the company's use of cash to pay an interim dividend. As a result, cash and cash equivalents decreased.
• Trade and other Current Receivables
Trade and other current receivables at the end of 2022 to 2024 were 185.74 million Baht, 144.03 million Baht, and 180.94 million Baht.
Most of the trade receivables are merchandise distributors who trade in merchandise distributors and have term credits. Including domestic trade receivables, the company has started to experiment with selling products with discounts and credit terms without commission to some members to test the market and sell them before they expire.
Trade accounts receivable as of 31 December 2023 decreased by 25.24 million Baht or 49.65 percent from 31 December 2022. This is due to the company’s declining sales to oversea distributors.
Trade accounts receivable as of 31 December 2024 increased by 64.23 million Baht or 250.90 percent from 31 December 2023. This is due to the company’s exporting more products to overseas distributors. In the last quarter of the year, the company sold a substantial volume of products to clear out stock before its expiration date, offering them at a discounted price and without commission. This strategy was implemented to test the market, especially targeting uninterested buyers in network marketing, but required the company's products in large quantities. Consequently, the company extended credit terms, which increased trade debtors.
Other receivable including trademark fee, service charges and commissions charged from distributors with detail as follows.
Other receivable as of 31 December 2024 decreased by 24.10 million Baht or 41.30 percent from 31 December 2023. This decrease was primarily due to a reduction in outstanding trademark fees, service fees, and commission fees from distributors, as well as the recognition of doubtful debts amounting to THB 15.08 million.
Goods prepaid expense as of 31 December 2023 decreased by 4.56 million Baht or 7.59 percent from 31 December 2022, according to receiving goods to prepare for sale, thus causing goods prepaid expense to decrease.
Goods prepaid expense as of 31 December 2024 decreased by 7.96 million Baht or 14.35 percent from 31 December 2023, according to receiving goods to prepare for sale, thus causing goods prepaid expense to decrease.
As of 31 December 2024, the company had 39.31 million Baht overdue debt on trade receivables and other receivables, and the overdue debt will be paid from distributors within 2025.
Doubtful Account Policy
The company has established a policy for setting aside doubtful debts 15.24 million Baht, by applying financial reporting standard No. 9 (TFRS9): financial instruments, impairment estimation and expected credit loss model, by considering past events, current situations, and forecast of future economic situations. (In the past, the company set aside doubtful debts when there were past and present indications that it would not be able to collect debts)
• Inventory
Inventories at the end of 2022 to 2024 were 68.27 million Baht, 117.04 million Baht, and 116.70 million Baht, which are consumer goods that the company is waiting for sale to businessmen or distributors.
Inventories as of December 31, 2023 increased by 48.77 million baht or 71.44 percent from December 31, 2022. The company has prepared products for sale in 2024, thus increasing inventories compared to the previous year.
Inventories as of December 31, 2024 decreased by 0.34 million baht or 0.29 percent from December 31, 2023. The company has prepared products for sale in 2025.
From 2022 to 2024, the company has the devaluation of inventories of 2.02 million Baht, 0.99 million Baht, and 2.20 million Baht, representing 2.96 percent, 0.85 percent, and 1.89 percent of the inventory value before deducting the allowance. The management estimates that it is at a normal level and there are not significant numbers.
• Other Current Asset
Other current assets at the end of 2022 to 2024 were 9.35 million Baht, 7.41 million Baht, and 1.60 million Baht, mainly consist of undue input vat.
Non-Current Asset
• Fixed Deposits Used as Collateral
Fixed deposits used as collateral at the end of 2022 to 2024 equal to 5.70 million Baht, 5.70 million Baht, and 5.82 million Baht, which is cash guaranteeing a working capital limit with a financial institution.
• Rights Asset
The company started recording rights assets from 1 January 2020, under Financial Reporting Standard No. 16 regarding lease agreements for rental items with a period of more than 1 year. Mostly, they are the rent for the location of the head office and branches of the company scattered throughout the country, with depreciation recorded (amortization) in each period according to the remaining period of the lease agreement. As of 31 December 2024, the company has right-of-use assets of 22.54 million Baht.
• Leasehold Improvements and Equipment
Leasehold improvements and equipment at the end of 2022 to 2024 were 87.45 million Baht, 81.49 million Baht, and 69.80 million Baht.
Leasehold improvements and equipment as of 31 December 2023 decreased by 5.96 million Baht or 6.82 percent from 31 December 2022, with the company selling old vehicles and buying a new car to compensate for business operations.
Leasehold improvements and equipment as of December 31, 2024, decreased by 11.69 million baht, or 14.35%, compared to December 31, 2023, due to the company's depreciation expenses for business operations.
• Goodwill
For the year 2024, goodwill of the company amounted to 1.07 million Baht that is an unchanged number from 2022. The company has successfully tested for the impairment of goodwill and the result shown there are no impairment.
• Intangible Asset
Intangible assets at the end of 2022 to 2027 were 130.09 million Baht, 119.75 million Baht, and 118.29 million Baht, which is mostly from business acquisitions, ERP systems, websites, applications, etc. Intangible assets from business acquisitions are recipes of supplements and cosmetics from the company's investment in SMI, a subsidiary of the group of the company, to operate as a manufacturing factory for the company. It was assessed by an independent appraiser to assess the value of know-how and the production expertise of the employees transferred from ZEN. In this regard, the company estimates that the recipes of dietary supplements and cosmetics can be used for the year 2024 amounted to 84.73 million Baht.
Intangible assets as of 31 December 2023 decreased by 10.34 million Baht or 7.94 percent from 31 December 2022, which was the normal amortization rate in 2023.
Intangible assets as of 31 December 2024 decreased by 1.46 million Baht or 1.22 percent from 31 December 2023, which was the normal amortization rate in 2024.
• Deferred Tax
Asset Deferred tax assets at the end of 2022 to 2024 were 0.00 million Baht, 0.00 million Baht, and 0.00 million Baht. This is due to the difference between accounting and tax expenses as a result of certain items, such as provisions for employee benefit obligations and the value of assets according to accounting is lower than income tax assets, etc. For the period of 2022 to 2023, the company has no deferred tax assets due to offsetting against the deferred tax liabilities.
• Non-Current Asset
Other non-current assets at the end of 2022 to 2024 were 4.68 million Baht, 12.17 million Baht, and 4.47 million Baht, which mostly consist of lease guarantee and utility expenses.
Source of Funds
• Appropriateness of the Capital Structure
The company has a debt-to-equity ratio of 0.33 times, 0.30 times, and 0.23 times at the end of 2022 to 2024 respectively.
The debt-to-equity ratio as of 31 December 2023 decreased by 0.03 times from 31 December 2022 due to the decrease in liabilities was greater than the decrease in shareholder equity, thus lowering the debt-to-equity ratio.
The debt-to-equity ratio as of 31 December 2024 decreased by 0.07 times from 31 December 2023 due to the decrease in liabilities was greater than the decrease in shareholder equity, thus lowering the debt-to-equity ratio.
Liability
Total debt at the end of 2022 to 2024 were 219.17 million Baht, 183.97 million Baht, and 126.80 million Baht, which mostly consist of trade and other current payables, lease liabilities, deferred tax liabilities.
• Trade and other Current Payables
Trade and other current payables at the end of 2022 to 2024 were 119.42 million Baht, 93.50 million Baht, and 58.81 million Baht
Trade and other current payables as of 31 December 2023 decreased by 25.92 million Baht or 21.70 percent from 31 December 2022, mainly due to the company having classified advance income as a current contract liability and accrued expenses decreased..
Trade and other current payables as of 31 December 2024 decreased by 37.09 million Baht or 38.67 percent from 31 December 2023, mainly due to the company having classified advance income as a current contract liability and accrued expenses decreased.
Unearned revenues consisted of products awaiting delivery, unearned product costs, membership fees awaiting recognition, etc., which are advance money and have not yet delivered the products and/or service.
Unearned revenue received as of 31 December 2023 increased by 14.39 million Baht or 76.34 percent from 31 December 2022, which was a transaction that classified advance income as a current contract liability.
Unearned revenue received as of 31 December 2024 increased by 2.06 million Baht or 46.19 percent from 31 December 2023, which was a transaction that classified advance income as a current contract liability.
• Accrued Income
Tax Accrued income tax at the end of 2022 to 2024 were 24.26 million Baht, 13.68 million Baht, and 0.59 million Baht, which was an additional net income tax from the operating results in each fiscal year.
• Other Current Liability
Other current liabilities at the end of 2022 to 2024 were 3.57 million Baht, 0.27 million Baht, and 0.26 million Baht respectively, which mainly was suspense tax.
Other current liabilities as of 31 December 2023 decreased by 0.89 million Baht or equivalent to 24.93% from 31 December 2022 since the company have a lower pending tax.
Other current liabilities as of 31 December 2024 decreased by 0.01 million Baht or equivalent to 3.70% from 31 December 2023 since the company have a lower pending tax.
• Other Non-Current Liability
Other non-current liabilities at the end of 2022 to 2024 equal to 0.00 million Baht, 0.00 million Baht, and 0.00 million Baht respectively.
• Financial Lease Liability
The liabilities under finance lease agreements at the end of 2022 to 2024 were 37.07 million Baht, 25.40 million Baht, and 27.25 million Baht.
As of 31 December 2023, the finance lease liabilities decreased by 11.67 million Baht from 31 December 31 2022, due to the recording of the amortization of lease liabilities in conjunction with right-of-use assets.
As of 31 December 2024, the finance lease liabilities increased by 1.85 million Baht from 31 December 31 2023, due to the recording of the amortization of lease liabilities in conjunction with right-of-use assets.
• Deferred Income Tax (Net)
Deferred income tax at the end of 2022 to 2024 were 17.46 million Baht, 14.28 million Baht, and 7.65 million Baht respectively, due to the adjustment of the fair value of net identifiable assets from the acquisition of SMI. As a result, the company has to record intangible assets such as recipes of dietary supplements and cosmetics with an increase of 126.17 million Baht (value as of 31 December 2020), resulting in deferred tax liabilities of 25.23 million Baht (20 percent of 126.17 million Baht). Also deducted deferred tax assets of, resulting in the company's net deferred tax liability of 7.65 million Baht.
Commitment and Contingent Liability
As of the end of 2022 to 2024, the company has commitments and contingent liabilities as follows
• Non-Current Provisions for Employee Benefits
The company has a non-current provision for employee benefits at the end of 2022 to 2024 equal to 17.38 million Baht, 21.09 million Baht, and 23.69 million Baht respectively.
Shareholders' Equity
Shareholders’ equity as of the end of 2022 to 2024 were 670.79 million Baht, 619.57 million Baht, and 550.16 million Baht.
Shareholders' equity as of 31 December 2023 decreased by 51.22 million Baht or 7.64 percent from 31 December 2022, from the decrease in retained earnings after the company paid an interim dividend on May 25, 2022.
Shareholders' equity as of 31 December 2024 decreased by 69.14 million Baht or 11.20 percent from 31 December 2023, due to a reduction in retained earnings following the company's dividend payments.
Debt Securities with Financial Ratio Requirements
Debt Securities with Financial Ratio Requirements Issued?
No
Factors That May Affect Financial Condition
Factors or Incidents That May Materially Affect Financial Condition
Major factors that may influence future operations and financial status
1. The company dependencies on Dr. Sitthawee Kriatchawanun and Mr. Noppakrit Nithilertvijit, who are the main executives, also considered as an important figure of the company. They also inspire other employees through training, seminar, and activities both inside and outside the organization related to the business. Therefore, these are the issue that both of them unable to continue working with the company and may cause the operation to be interrupted, and affect the performance and financial status of the company.
2. The operation in Myanmar is in the form of selling products to the dealers and followed the form of networking business which depend on related legal in Myanmar. The company executive expected that there will be more legal clarity in Myanmar. However, the management has a policy of delaying the sale of products to dealers in Myanmar according to the market conditions forecasting, to prevent the risk from inability to pay for goods. As a result, revenue from operations in Myanmar may slow down during the time that legally in Myanmar still unclear.
3. Commission fee, which is the compensation paid to the businessmen according to the networking business plan, is considered as the company’s significant expenses. It sums up to 41.09 percent, 36.37 percent, and 36.80 percent for 2022, 2023, and 2024 respectively. In the case of the proportion of such expense was significantly increased may be due to the businessmen received higher commission even if they did not buy more products from the company, and will affect the company’s net profit margin. However, the company monitors this expense ratio regularly. In addition, at the end of the year, the company implemented a reduction price strategy to gain greater access to consumers, combined with a reduction in the point value (PV) of each item used in the calculation of commission, which would result in company's reduced commission rate adjustment to a level suitable for business operations and increased opportunity to generate profits company.

